_{First a message from our friends at The Oxford Club (sponsor)}

Dear Reader,

I want to show you something that might make you upset.

For decades, the biggest banks in America have been using a secret account to collect an average of 29% per year.

Your bank never told you about it. It's never been advertised to the general public.

But since 2000, this single account has turned $1,000 into over $556,454.

Not by picking hot stocks. Not by timing the market.

Just by parking money in an account that has averaged 29%... year after year after year.

The big banks knew about it. You didn't.

That changes today.

Click here to see how "The 29% Account" works – and how you can open one yourself.

Good investing,

Marc Lichtenfeld
Chief Income Strategist, The Oxford Club

P.S. Anyone can open a "29% Account." It doesn't matter if you're 18 or 81. Have $500 or $5 million. Click here for the full details.

Wayfair is getting punished this morning, and the size of the drop matters: this isn’t a sleepy 2–3% wobble. Multiple premarket prints and headlines have the stock down roughly 11%–13%, with premarket pricing around $80 after a prior close near $91.48.

When a stock gaps down double digits after earnings, the market is telling you two things at once:

So let’s break it down the right way: what the numbers actually said, why the stock is down anyway, and how to trade it without letting volatility trade you.

From early coverage and the company’s release, Wayfair posted Q4 2025 results that were strong on the adjusted lens:

Those are not “bad quarter” numbers. If you were trading only the adjusted view, you’d expect the stock to catch a bid.

But the market didn’t trade the adjusted story.

It traded the messier story.

Two things can be true at the same time:

A) GAAP loss and non-operational charges hit sentiment
Barron’s highlighted that Wayfair’s unadjusted results looked far worse, including an unadjusted loss around -$0.89 per share, driven by items like equity-based compensation and a $165M loss tied to debt repurchases.

That matters because in a post-2022 market, investors are allergic to anything that looks like “financial engineering costs” or “noise that won’t go away.” Even if those items are explainable, they muddy the narrative on a day when traders want clarity.

B) The customer number didn’t confirm the growth narrative
Wayfair ended 2025 with 21.3M active customers, down about 0.5% YoY.

This is the subtle part: Wayfair can show revenue growth, margin improvement, and better profitability, but if the active customer base is flat-to-down, the market starts asking:

Even if the answers are “it’s fine,” the stock can still de-rate in the short term if that metric doesn’t reinforce the bull story.

C) The stock had already run hard into earnings
Wayfair was up roughly ~99% over the last 12 months per Investing.com’s earnings recap.

That matters. A stock that doubled off its lows doesn’t need a “good quarter.” It needs a quarter that justifies the new price. When the stock is priced for improvement, the slightest narrative friction can trigger profit-taking.

This is the setup you’re seeing this morning: a fundamentally improving company, in a stock that had already priced in a lot of that improvement.

The most useful way to trade earnings is to separate operating improvement from optics.

Operating improvement (bullish inputs):

Optics friction (bearish inputs):

That’s the exact cocktail that creates a big premarket dump:

Premarket prints put Wayfair around $80 versus $91.48 prior close—roughly a -12% to -13% gap.

That creates three important technical facts for active traders:

Your job is to identify which day you’re in.

When it happens:
The stock opens weak, flushes, then forms a higher low and reclaims VWAP (or holds above it on retests).

What you’re looking for:

Why it’s tradable:
A lot of downside is already “forced” in the gap. If institutions agree the adjusted profit story is real, they often buy the panic—especially in a name that’s still linked to housing normalization and consumer resilience.

Risk control:

When it happens:
The stock bounces early, but can’t hold above VWAP; it forms lower highs and rolls over.

What you’re looking for:

Why it’s tradable:
This is what a true “earnings repricing” looks like: the market uses bounces to sell, not to accumulate. That tends to produce clean intraday trends.

Risk control:

This is the one most traders ignore, and it’s often the highest-quality decision.

If Wayfair spends the day chopping, unable to reclaim VWAP cleanly but also refusing to break lower, it’s telling you: the market needs time.

In that case, the better swing setup often arrives in 2–5 sessions as the stock:

This is especially relevant when the fundamental story is improving but the optics spooked traders—exactly what we have here.

If you’re thinking beyond today, Wayfair’s next tradable upside phase usually requires at least one of these catalysts:

Let’s frame it in price logic instead of storytelling.

The key point: earnings gaps create new maps. Old support/resistance becomes less relevant than today’s levels.

Wayfair is down big this morning because the market saw a mix of “real operational improvement” and “messy optics.”

Strategy: Don’t guess. Let the first 30–60 minutes print the truth. Then trade one of three setups: gap reversal, failed-bounce trend, or patience until a base forms._{Editorial Disclaimer}

_{This commentary is for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. All market strategies involve risk, and past performance is not indicative of future results. Readers should conduct their own analysis or consult a licensed financial professional before making investment decisions.}